Sam Levy's choice for The Only Living Pickpocket in New York created a technical puzzle that rental houses and cinematographers rarely discuss explicitly: how do you make vintage prime lenses sit visually alongside a modern zoom lens on a contemporary digital sensor? The solution he and his rental house, TCS Camera in New York, arrived at was ingenious: detune the Optimo zoom to match the organic qualities of the vintage Bausch and Lomb Super Baltars.
The technical challenge is specific. The vintage Super Baltars and original Baltars produce halation and organic softness at highlights. These are not precision tools. They are expressive optics that impose themselves on the image. A modern zoom lens like the ARRI Optimo 28-340 is engineered to be as optically neutral as possible—to render the image with minimal optical signature so that the DIT's color grade, not the lens' optical character, determines the final look. When a cinematographer uses both lens sets in the same film, the cut between prime and zoom can feel jarring because the optical character changes.
Levy's solution was to have Oliver Schietinger at TCS Camera "detune" the Optimo zoom. Detuning means introducing controlled optical softness, reducing the sharpness of the optic, intentionally degrading the clinical precision that the modern zoom was engineered to provide. The goal was not to make the zoom soft—that would create other problems. The goal was to make the zoom sit comfortably alongside the vintage primes, taking the edge off its modern sharpness while preserving visual continuity across the zoom and prime combination.
This is a rare technical procedure. Most rental houses and cinematographers do not discuss detuning because it represents a deliberate rejection of the lens manufacturer's optical design. ARRI engineers the Optimo to be sharp and neutral. Deliberately reducing that sharpness seems like destroying expensive equipment. But when the cinematographic goal is visual coherence across heterogeneous lens sets, detuning becomes a necessary tool.
The technical execution requires precision. The detuning has to be controlled enough that the zoom still performs its primary function—zooming smoothly from 28mm to 340mm—while introducing just enough optical softness that the rendering is consistent with the vintage primes. Too much softness and the zoom becomes unusable. Too little and the inconsistency between zoom and prime remains visible. The cinematographer and rental house have to test extensively to find the correct amount of detuning.
British Cinematographer confirmed Levy's description: the detuned Optimo works alongside the Baltars, creating visual continuity without requiring the cinematographer to avoid zooming or cutting between zoom and prime footage. The solution allows the cinematography to be flexible—primes for specific moments, zoom for moments requiring different focal length ratios—while maintaining a unified visual language.
For cinematographers working with mixed lens sets—a common contemporary practice where budget requires combining expensive vintage rentals with more accessible modern glass—the detuning approach offers a technical solution. The key is finding a rental house that understands optical engineering well enough to denude modern precision glass safely and effectively. TCS Camera's willingness to engage in this kind of bespoke technical work is increasingly rare.
The vintage-digital combination that Levy uses—Super Baltars from the 1960s on the ARRI Alexa 35—is now the predominant aesthetic of festival circuit independent cinema. The grammar is: old glass, new sensor, detuned middle ground to bridge them. This combination allows cinematographers to capture the organic quality of vintage optics with the dynamic range and resolution that contemporary exhibition requires. The compromise is that it is not authentic to either era. But it is a third visual language that has become cinematographically rigorous and immediately recognizable.
Gear Recommendations
- ARRI Alexa 35 | Adorama – B&H Photo
Note: Links above are affiliate links. Occupy Cinematography may earn a commission on qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.